- Imp-Subjective Order-All matters-20090616-174916
Countermedia has transcribed this tape in a comment below. Please crosscheck.
Categories
- announcements (6)
- assigned (36)
- crosschecked (20)
- Ganu (10)
- pls crosscheck (57)
- R Sridharan (1)
- Rajdeep Sardesai (1)
Recent posts
- Status on 7 December 2010
- What have people been Googline to reach this blog?
- Status
- See how Tony works-20090602-085554
- Some imp advisor from Tata-20090616-135007
- Some IS-20090706-185337
- Whose gas is it anyway-20090706-104041
- Vir-his letter-MDA interview-20090620-120959
- Vinu-fudged RCOM figs-gas-Curse on AmarSingh-20090616-200515
- Vinu-article on national assets-20090622-081358
- Vinu perhaps-All issues-mainly spectrum-20090616-195137
- Upendra- AI story-20090620-202732
- To Rakesh- Govt is respondet-20090707-185151
- Tata writing to Power Ministry-20090708-111257
- Tarun-AI-Batting for Jadhav-20090708-085321
Archives
- December 2010 (2)
- November 2010 (116)
Join 12 other subscribers
ADA
Anil Ambani
Arun Shourie
Barkha Dutt
BJP
CNBC
Forbes India
Forbes magazine
Inderjit Gupta
India Today
Kanimozhi
K Raja
Mukesh Ambani
Network 18
Niira Radia
Power
Prabhu Chawla
Radia Tapes
Raghav Behl
Rahul Joshi
Reliance Communications
Reliance telecom
SEBI
Senthil
Sharad Yadav
Shiv Sena
Shohbaa De
Shrinath
Supreme Court
Tata
Venkaiah Naidu
Vir Sanghvi
Reading Radia 
(I am keeping the name as unknown voice since the name does not seem to be clear)
UV: Niira
NR: You called
NR: hello
UV: Yep
NR: you called, (name not clear)
UV: Yep
NR: What.
UV: Where are you
NR: At Home
UV: Having fun
NR: I have been on the phone since morning
UV: Why…
NR: You Know, I tell you one thing.I went through the judgement. You know there are things in the judgement that has. even If you Look at the scope of the judgement. It is only been written by a lawyer.
UV: HMMM
NR: It’s not written by a judge. You can tell that by from way it has been written.
Secondly there are things that have been said in the judgement For eg: In one of the points 308 which you would be critical in your argument.
UV: Like what?
NR: Like, In The board meeting. The minutes of the board meeting its said that the particular decision has been annulled.
UV: hmmmm
NR: The minutes says that it has been annulled. Right.
UV: hmmmm
NR: The minutes of the court says that but there was some errr.. tacit a understanding and wrongdoing to Anil Ambani.
UV: hmmm
NR: It’s subjective. (PAUSE)
The full minutes were never presented in the court. From either side how does they know. It’s not part of any submission.
uv: (Not clear)
NR: No. That is small. The Other thing is that I have been pushing in the media to the editors has been – court. They did this diversion of court. … Right. … How could that happen. Third part. They did it post the event.Right
UV: Hmmm
NR: Then happened Spectrum. How did spectrum happen. Restrospect. …………TDSAT. ….Sunil Mittal and everybody went to supreme court.
….Court-High Court. That apart went to Supreme Court
UV: Hmmm
NR: Then came gas. How can a natural asset of the country be decided by a judge who is deciding on an MoU between two brothers. who ever the brothers are. It doesnt matter. Either of the brothers have no right. So
UV: How are people reacting to that?
NR: All three natural resources.
UV: Hmmm
NR: Fourth point. Iron ore mines in Jharkhand.
UV: Hmmm
NR: He is asking for iron ore mine when he doesnt even have steel plant. He is asking for gas when he doesnt even have power plant.
UV: Hmmm
NR: What is his attempt. His attempt is: I Anil Ambani. I am trying to take all natural resources of the country for personal profit. Therefore natural resources cannot be decided by a government.I mean Cannot be decided by a department like Shinde or Raja. Cannot be decided by a state government in the case of iron ore and coal.
UV: Hmmm
NR: Spectrum cannot be decided by Mr Raja again. It cannot be decided by
regional parties.
UV: Hmmm
NR: It has to be decided through a one policy mechanism at the top which can happen only at the purview of the prime minister. It doesnt matter who it is. It doesnt matter if Mukesh Ambani. It doesnt matter if Tata.
UV: New argument.Is it? But how people responding to it?
NR: Very very positive.Every body agrees because
if you talk about Yeddiyurappa in Karnataka with Bellary. You TALK about Madhu Koda asking 150 crores per mine. Who the. Everyone today knows the mining scam.Who doesnt know that. Right. It is the natural resource of the country. Spectrum. They are in court. It has been a dispute for last six years.
UV: Come. We will do a half an hour of this tomorrow.
NR: It’s a very valid fact.
UV: hAAN.
NR: It cannot be…
UV: inaudible
[Ends abruptly]
Edits marked in bold.
UV: Niira
NR: You called
NR: hello
UV: Yep
NR: you called, (name not clear) Note: This seems to be “Darling”?
UV: Yep
NR: What.
UV: Where are you
NR: At Home
UV: Having fun
NR: (Note: I think she says the name here, it’s not very audible.)>I have been on the phone
since morning
UV: Why…
NR: You Know, I tell you one thing.I went through the judgement. You know there are things in the
judgement that has. even If you Look at the scope of the judgement. It is only been (there’s no
“been”) written by a lawyer.
UV: HMMM
NR: It’s not written by a judge. You can tell that by from way it has been written.
Secondly there are things that have been said in the judgement For eg: In one of the points 308
which you would be critical in your argument.
(which he would not be privy to, it was never in arguments)
UV: Like what?
NR: Like, In The board meeting. The minutes of the board meeting its said that the particular
decision has been annulled.
UV: hmmmm
NR: The minutes says that it has been annulled. Right.
UV: hmmmm
NR: The minutes of the court (Edit: should be “board”)says that but there was some errr..
tacit a understanding and wrongdoing to Anil Ambani.
UV: hmmm
NR: It’s subjective. (PAUSE)
The full minutes were never presented in the court. From either side how does they know. It’s not
part of any submission.
( He’s subjective. (PAUSE) He…The board minutes were never presented in the court. Bu either
side. How does he know? It’s not part of any submission.)
uv: (Not clear) (That’s pretty serious. So then?)
NR: No. That is small. The Other thing is that I have been pushing in the media to the editors has
been – court. They did this diversion of court. … Right. … How could that happen. Third part. They
did it post the event.Right
(Edit: NR: No. That is small. That is another thing. Now, the Other thing is that I have been
pushing in the media since morning with the editors has been – Coal. They did this diversion of
coal. Right? Sasan. How did that happen? Third part. They did it post the event. Right?
UV: Hmmm
NR: Then happened Spectrum. How did spectrum happen. Restrospect. …………TDSAT. ….Sunil Mittal and
everybody went to supreme court.
….Court-High Court. That apart went to Supreme Court
Edit:
NR: Then happened Spectrum. How did spectrum happen. Restrospect. (inaudible) to technology. Fixed
went to TDSAT. TDSAT. Sunil Mittal and everybody went to supreme court. Coal-High Court. Tata Power
went to Supreme Court
UV: Hmmm
NR: Then came gas. How can a natural asset of the country be decided by a judge who is deciding on
an MoU between two brothers. who ever the brothers are. It doesnt matter. Either of the brothers
have no right. So Add: all three…
UV: How are people reacting to that?
NR: All three natural resources.
UV: Hmmm
NR: Fourth point. Iron ore mines in Jharkhand.
UV: Hmmm
NR: He is asking for iron ore mine when he doesnt even have steel plant. He is asking for gas when
he doesnt even have power plant.
UV: Hmmm
NR: What is his attempt. His attempt is: I Anil Ambani. I am trying to take all natural resources
of the country for personal profit. Therefore natural resources cannot be decided by a government.I
mean Cannot be decided by a department like Shinde or Raja. Cannot be decided by a state government
in the case of iron ore and coal.
UV: Hmmm
NR: Spectrum cannot be decided by Mr Raja again. It cannot be decided by
regional parties.
UV: Hmmm
NR: It has to be decided through a one policy mechanism at the top which can happen only at the
purview of the prime minister. It doesnt matter who it is. It doesnt matter if Add: it’s
Mukesh Ambani. It doesnt matter if Add: it is Tata.
UV: New argument.Is it? But how Add: are people responding to it?
NR: Very very positive.Every body agrees because
if you talk about Yeddiyurappa in Karnataka with Bellary. You TALK about Madhu Koda asking 150
crores per mine. Who the. Everyone today knows the mining scam.Who doesnt know that. Right. It is
the natural resource of the country. Spectrum. They are in court. It has been a dispute for last
six years.
UV: Come. We will do a half an hour of this tomorrow.
NR: It’s a very valid fact.
Edit:
NR: Very very positive. Everybody agrees because
if you talk about Yeddiyurappa in Karnataka with Bellary. You talk about Madhu Koda asking 150
crores per mine. Who the…Everyone today knows the mining scam. Who doesnt know that, right? It is
a natural resource of the country. Spectrum. They are in court. It has been a dispute for last six
years.
UV: Okay. Come. We will do a half an hour on this tomorrow.
NR: But it’s a very valid fact.
UV: hAAN.
NR: It cannot be…
UV: inaudible ( Accha, so what..)
[Ends abruptly]
Thanks, it’s on the OL site now